English semantics: Difference between revisions

From FirespeakerWiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
No edit summary
 
(11 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 8: Line 8:
* "since" means something is still ongoing
* "since" means something is still ongoing
* "starting" doesn't mean it's still ongoing
* "starting" doesn't mean it's still ongoing
=== since, because ===
* "because" seems to explain the reasoning behind the matrix clause's semantics
* "since" seems to more remind the interlocutor of the reasoning behind the matrix clause's semantics


=== watch, look at ===
=== watch, look at ===
Line 16: Line 20:
* "hurry up" if activity has already started
* "hurry up" if activity has already started
* "be quick" if activity hasn't started yet
* "be quick" if activity hasn't started yet
=== out, outside ===
* "out" = not at the house = somewhere else
* "outside" = not in the house = but often at the house (i.e., not out)
=== go home, go inside  ===
similar to out, outside
* "go home" means you're not near the house, it's not about going into the house
* "go inside" means going into the house (or other structure), once you're already near it
=== before, until ===
* "before" if event has a stage that can start or end preceding reference event
* "until" if event has stages or iterations that can continue preceding reference event and end upon reference event
Or maybe it's just about the presence ("before") or absence ("until") of a gap of time between the event and the reference event.
=== that's why, so ===
both explain that the thing before is a reason for the thing after, but they differ in their uses:
* "that's why" if you've already talked about the thing after it ("that's why I went shopping")
* "so" if you haven't already talked about the thing after it ("so I went shopping")
=== even though, even if ===
* "even though" makes the matrix phrase depend on something that actually happened/happens/will happen
* "even if" makes the matrix phrase depend on something that is only hypothetical
=== take, get ===
* "take" seems to add a nuance of someone else being deprived of something
* "get" can still involve being an active agent in making oneself receive something
=== carry, pick up, lift ===
* "carry" (activity) means the agent already is holding the patient (has picked it up)
* "pick up" (achievement/accomplishment) is about the agent acquiring the patient, and feels a bit inchoative
* "lift" is about either an agent moving a patient up (achievement) or the agent holding a patient up (state)
=== wear, put on ===
* "put on" is like an inchoative version of "wear"

Latest revision as of 16:22, 27 November 2025

These word pairs have essentially the same meaning, but differ in semantics by a distinction that isn't made in certain other languages I know. This makes these distinctions lexical selection issues in machine translation.

say, tell

  • "say" takes as a required complement the utterance/thing said; the person told is optional
  • "tell" takes as a required complement the person told something; the utterance/thing said is optional

since, starting

  • "since" means something is still ongoing
  • "starting" doesn't mean it's still ongoing

since, because

  • "because" seems to explain the reasoning behind the matrix clause's semantics
  • "since" seems to more remind the interlocutor of the reasoning behind the matrix clause's semantics

watch, look at

  • "watch" if something changes or has the potential to change
  • "look at" if something is static

hurry up, be quick

  • "hurry up" if activity has already started
  • "be quick" if activity hasn't started yet

out, outside

  • "out" = not at the house = somewhere else
  • "outside" = not in the house = but often at the house (i.e., not out)

go home, go inside

similar to out, outside

  • "go home" means you're not near the house, it's not about going into the house
  • "go inside" means going into the house (or other structure), once you're already near it

before, until

  • "before" if event has a stage that can start or end preceding reference event
  • "until" if event has stages or iterations that can continue preceding reference event and end upon reference event

Or maybe it's just about the presence ("before") or absence ("until") of a gap of time between the event and the reference event.

that's why, so

both explain that the thing before is a reason for the thing after, but they differ in their uses:

  • "that's why" if you've already talked about the thing after it ("that's why I went shopping")
  • "so" if you haven't already talked about the thing after it ("so I went shopping")

even though, even if

  • "even though" makes the matrix phrase depend on something that actually happened/happens/will happen
  • "even if" makes the matrix phrase depend on something that is only hypothetical

take, get

  • "take" seems to add a nuance of someone else being deprived of something
  • "get" can still involve being an active agent in making oneself receive something

carry, pick up, lift

  • "carry" (activity) means the agent already is holding the patient (has picked it up)
  • "pick up" (achievement/accomplishment) is about the agent acquiring the patient, and feels a bit inchoative
  • "lift" is about either an agent moving a patient up (achievement) or the agent holding a patient up (state)

wear, put on

  • "put on" is like an inchoative version of "wear"